"My grandmother took in boarders," he says. "This boarder, an actor, brought a young
woman over who wanted to discuss her relationship with the Shorts. And . . .
looking back at all this, I realize this was Elizabeth Short, who was
trying to trace her father. The girl was there for a long time. I remember
talking to her. I remember her very clearly."
At the time, John's father was a police officer working on the Black Dahlia case.
"He had these photographs of the girl's face inside this portfolio," John says.
"My grandmother made me promise that I would not tell my father that that person
[Elizabeth] had been in the house. She thought that it might reflect badly [on
my father] and would have gotten him in trouble with the LAPD. Why would a
murder victim come to the house?"
Whatever motivated the killer remains a mystery, but one thing is certainly
clear to John about Elizabeth Short: "She encountered somebody who absolutely
believed she had to die. And, in so doing, left this parcel on the doorstep of
popular culture that we will never, ever, ever forget."
Gilmore's monologue makes me recall an L.A. Times article I had read
about the Black Dahlia murder case. Los Angeles Times writer Jack Smith had
been working at the Daily News when a police call came in the early
morning of Jan.15,1947.
"Within the minute, I had written what i nay have been the first sentence ever
written on the Black Dahlia case," Smith remembered.
"My lead went pretty much like this: 'The nude body of a young woman, neatly cut in
two at the waist, was found early today on a vacant lot near Crenshaw and
Exposition boulevards.'"
But, Smith said, when he opened the paper, he noted a small but significant addition:
the word "beautiful" placed between "a" and "young woman."
"Our city editor, of course, no more knew what the unfortunate young woman had looked
like than I did. But the lesson was clear: at the Daily News, at least,
all young women whose nude bodies were found in two pieces on vacant lots were
beautiful. I never forgot it."
I videotape Gilmore exploring the Dahlia's apartment and remarking on all of the
remodeling that has occurred over the years. There's a knock on the door.
Dawn La Rue, music supervisor and composer of the soundtrack for
Sex, Death and the Hollywood Mystique shows up in full Black Dahlia drag. I stalk her with
my video camera through the fifth floor hallway of the apartment building before
we move on to the beautiful Bradbury building where John had an office while
researching his book Severed (which has been optioned three years in a
row by David Lynch, director of Eraserhead).
Our next stop is The Hollywood Memorial Park Cemetery. The "Hollywood" sign, the
Griffith Park Observatory and the Paramount Studios water tower can all be seen
from this sacred dead-celebrity sanctuary. I videotape underground screen sirens
Kerrine Eikins (star of J. Michael McCarthy's The Sore Losers} and Eva
Ford (Star of Emmy Collins's Headshot) dancing in the Cathedral Mausoleum
and tearfully placing flowers at the graves of Rudolph Valentine, Cecil B.
DeMille and Tyron Power. John leans against a tombstone and tries to define the
"Hollywood mystique."
"Hollywood has its own separate way of life. It's a hermetically sealed
environment, and what goes on here, nobody knows about in the outside world. The
fans know one side of it, but that side really doesn't exist. That's not how it
really is. The mystique of Hollywood is really because it's a mystery. What's
manufactured here is motion pictures - an imitation of life, basically what is
understood by the world at large as a real fact, but it's not. Ifs not the real
life that goes on here. The real life is right here - death. The image dies. The
man dies ... What is an icon? I recently was asked about James Dean, Marilyn
Monroe and Elvis Presley as icons, but an icon is something that we manufacture.
It's a product. It's a big, big business to manufacture icons. However, there
are some people who are buried here who really gave a lot more of themselves to
the world."
The next day, accompanied by Carmen Feliciana and The Goddess Bunny (star of my
transgender documentary, Sugar and Spice}, I videotape an homage to
Sharon Tate and her unborn child, Paul Richard Polanski, at The Holy Cross
Cemetery in Culver City. Bela Lugosi, Rita Hayworth, Bing Crosby, Jackie
Coogan, Ray Bolger and Mario Lanza are a few of the movie stars buried at Holy
Cross.
In the foreword to The Garbage People,
Gilmore's book about the killers of
Sharon Tate, he describes Charles Manson: "He was a very imaginative and
energetic and charismatic man, and Polanski is right in a sense, that he was
an artist, and he was spurned, as was Smitty, and Starkweather - all would-be
artists, thwarted or spurned, and getting even by their murderous rages. . . .
Others have killed but the chemical ingredients to make them stars just
weren't on the menu. We're in a 'star system,' and being a star is what it's all
about. Jimmy Dean and Janis Joplin and Lenny Bruce became stars in other ways.
Manson is a star. It's no wonder his face is on T-shirts."
As of this writing, I continue to shoot
Sex, Death and the Hollywood Mystique.. It's evening now, and, with camcorder rolling,
I continue to travel through the heart of darkest Hollywood. I look up at the Hollywood sign that hovers over Los
Angeles like a hungry vulture. I think about the British actress, Peg Entwhistle,
who in 1932 committed suicide by Jumping off the big letter H. Carmen Feliciana
and I drive out of Los Angeles into the Mojave desert. We step out of the car.
Gazing into the night sky, we smile . . . real stars!